• Richtek RT3602AH equivalent?

Pravila foruma:Klikni tukaj za prikaz pravil na forumu

  1. Naslov teme mora vsebovati: proizvajalca naprave, poln model in kratek opis okvare.
  2. Sporočilo teme mora vsebovati: oznako tiskanega vezja (v primeru popravil strojne opreme), razširjen opis okvare, kaj je bilo preverjeno, zamenjano in/ali izmerjeno, sklep in vprašanje. Če ne morete najti oznake tiskanega vezja, morate prebrati TO TEMO. Če še vedno ne najdete oznake, prosim objavite kakovostne fotografije obeh strani matične plošče - potrebno je odstraniti vse folije in module, ki bi lahko zakrivali te oznake.
  3. Pred objavo nove teme, preberite vse teme v podforumu USPOSABLJANJA, in naredite predhodno diagnostiko na podlagi vsebine teh usposabljanj.
  4. Nalaganje celotnih navodil/shem, BIOS / firmware datotek, ali objavljanje povezav, ki vodijo do drugih spletnih strani s takšnimi datotekami, je SROGO PREPOVEDANO. Lahko objavite le majhen del navodil/shem, ali povezavo na BIOS datoteko v podforumu NEVERIFICIRANE DATOTEKE BIOS/EFI. V eni temi ne smete objaviti več kot eno stran navodil/shem. Datoteka ne sme vsebovati vidnih žigov "zaupno",, e-poštnih naslovov ipd.
  5. V eni temi lahko opišete SAMO eno napravo. Za vsako drugo okvarjeno napravo morate odpreti novo temo.
  6. Zahteve za sheme, boardview, fotografije matičnih plošč, datoteke BIOS-a ali servisne priročnike za storitve NISO DOVOLJENE. Če želite vprašati za katero koli od teh, odprite novo temo v podforumu ZAHTEVA ZA DOKUMENTACIJO & DATOTEKO BIOS/EFI.

#1 Richtek RT3602AH equivalent?


Napisal/-a Mobotool 22 Oktober 2023, 22:24
Has someone ever tried to replace a Richtek RT3602AH with an NCP81206A (or NCP81236A)?
Or can someone give me advices to proceed or not?

I have two boards, one working Lenovo NM-C121 with CPU i3 (RT3602AH used in Single Phase) and one not-working HP Quanta 0PA with an i5 (broken RT3602AH in 2-phase mode with RT9610C to control the second phase).
Since I can't receive a new RT3602AH soon, and I have two new NCPs (one 81206A and one 81236A) I thought about swapping the two ones, putting the NCP81206A on the NM-C121 and the RT3602AH on the HP board that needs 2-phase work.

Comparing datasheets of the Richtek and OnSemi ICs, I see that they have almost the same 52 pins (same VCC, GND, EN, PWM etc pins), and they are made for IMVP8 platforms, but the Richtek one has pin 2 5 and 6 designed to regulate some inner settings, called SET1 SET2 and SET3, and in the application circuit they are only connected to a few resistors.
Instead, the OnSemi ones 2, 5 and 6 have other functions called DIFFOUT, ILIM and CSCOMP.

According to you, would this swap be possible without risking to fry the CPU on the Lenovo NM-C121 board?

Re: Richtek RT3602AH equivalent?


Napisal/-a Google Adsense [BOT] 22 Oktober 2023, 22:24

#2 Re: Richtek RT3602AH equivalent?  [REŠENO]


Napisal/-a Vogelek23 22 Oktober 2023, 23:39
The crucial difference is also with pin 46. RT3602AH chip uses this pin to output the reference 0.6V voltage to offset the IMON output voltage and must have a very specific components connected to it. NCP81206A chip uses this pin to limit the output current of VCCSA rail. In my opinion, these ICs are not directly interchangeable.

#3 Re: Richtek RT3602AH equivalent?


Napisal/-a Mobotool 24 Oktober 2023, 00:25
I understand master Vogelek, thank you for your advice

Re: Richtek RT3602AH equivalent?


Napisal/-a Google Adsense [BOT] 24 Oktober 2023, 00:25

Kdo je na strani

Po forumu brska: matic in 4 gostov

_______________________________
Vse pravice pridržane. Nepooblaščeno kopiranje vsebine te spletne strani ali njenega dela je strogo prepovedano.
Vse blagovne znamke, izdelki ali storitve, objavljene na tej spletni strani, pripadajo njihovim zakonitim lastnikom, so avtorsko zaščitene in se uporabljajo samo v informativne namene.